Why Hae-Young's Handwritten Apology Caused Controversy: A Step-by-Step Breakdown
The Core Controversy of Hae-Young's Handwritten Apology
Hae-Young recently discovered his great-grandfather's pro-Japanese activities and issued a handwritten apology on August 12, 2026. In the statement, he expressed shame for having boasted about his family history without knowledge of it, apologized as a descendant, and promised to study historical records. However, he omitted specific references to his great-grandfather identified as a pro-Japanese collaborator, drawing criticism. The apology was posted on Chinese social media before being abruptly deleted on August 14, amplifying the controversy.

Publication and Media Coverage of the Apology
Hae-Young shared his handwritten apology after learning about his great-grandfather's pro-Japanese activities. The statement expressed remorse for boasting about family history without knowledge, apologized as a descendant, and promised to study history. This was presented as an official response to the controversy surrounding his great-grandfather's collaboration with Japan, reported by Nate and KBS News on August 12, 2026.
The apology gained further attention after being posted on Chinese social media but deleted abruptly on August 14. While the reason for deletion was not disclosed, it led to increased public backlash. The absence of mention of his great-grandfather's pro-Japanese activities and a surge in followers (200,000) were seen as potential noise marketing tactics, though public anger persisted. Additional coverage regarding the deletion reason emerged on August 15.
Public sentiment remained cold after the apology, with criticism focusing on the omission of specific references to his great-grandfather's pro-Japanese activities. A report by the editorial team of the Pro-Japanese Collaborators Encyclopedia had identified Hae-Young's great-grandfather as a collaborator, but the apology lacked explicit acknowledgment.
Apology Deletion and Additional Controversy
Hae-Young posted his handwritten apology on Chinese social media before deleting it abruptly on August 14. This appears to be a response to criticism that the statement used vague terms like 'family history' instead of specific references to pro-Japanese activities. After deletion, issues with the omission of mention of his great-grandfather and the follower increase (200,000) were seen as noise marketing effects, though public anger continued.
On August 15, additional media coverage about the reason for deletion emerged, but no official explanation was provided. This led to further speculation, though the exact reason remains unknown. On August 25, renewed criticism arose regarding filming preparations for 'Severe Trauma Center' Season 2, adding to the ongoing backlash.
The apology's lack of specific reference to his great-grandfather's pro-Japanese activities was criticized as a flaw ('a blemish on an otherwise good thing'). This stemmed from insufficient acknowledgment of his great-grandfather being identified as a collaborator. Additionally, the omission of mention of his 'great-grandfather from Surokdo' drew further criticism.
Aftermath and Public Reaction
Following the apology, Hae-Young's follower count increased by 200,000, which analysts attributed to noise marketing effects. However, public anger persisted, with sentiment remaining cold. During the initial announcement, Hae-Young stated he was 'sorry for his great-grandfather's involvement' but used vague language rather than specific apology, reinforcing criticism from the Pro-Japanese Collaborators Encyclopedia editorial team.
Even after deleting the apology, public sentiment remained cold, with further criticism over the omission of mention of his 'great-grandfather from Surokdo.' This was seen as a failure to include specific acknowledgment of pro-Japanese activities in the statement.
Timeline and Related Coverage
Hae-Young issued his handwritten apology on August 12, 2026, following recent discovery of his great-grandfather's pro-Japanese activities. The statement expressed shame for boasting about family history without knowledge, apologized as a descendant, and promised to study history.
The apology was posted on Chinese social media before being deleted on August 14. This appears to be due to criticism over the use of vague terms like 'family history' instead of specific references to pro-Japanese activities.
On August 15, additional coverage regarding the deletion reason emerged but no explanation was provided. Further speculation arose about the exact cause, though it remains unclear. On August 25, renewed criticism surfaced over filming preparations for 'Severe Trauma Center' Season 2, adding to ongoing backlash.
The omission of mention of his great-grandfather from Surokdo became a point of criticism. While the Pro-Japanese Collaborators Encyclopedia editorial team identified Hae-Young's great-grandfather as a collaborator, the apology lacked specific acknowledgment, leading to significant criticism.
Core Content and Controversy
In his handwritten apology, Hae-Young expressed shame for boasting about family history without knowledge, apologized as a descendant, and promised to study history. However, he omitted specific references to his great-grandfather's pro-Japanese activities, drawing criticism.
The apology was posted on Chinese social media before being deleted on August 14, amplifying the controversy. This appears to be due to the use of vague terms like 'family history' instead of specific references to pro-Japanese activities. Following deletion, issues with the omission of mention of his great-grandfather and follower count increase (200,000) were seen as noise marketing effects, though public anger persisted.
The 200,000 follower increase after the apology was analyzed as a result of noise marketing. However, public anger continued, with sentiment remaining cold. The omission of mention of his 'great-grandfather from Surokdo' also drew criticism.
Hae-Young issued the apology to formally address the controversy over his great-grandfather's pro-Japanese activities but faced criticism for using vague language rather than specific references. This reinforced criticism from the Pro-Japanese Collaborators Encyclopedia editorial team.
On August 25, renewed criticism emerged regarding filming preparations for 'Severe Trauma Center' Season 2, occurring while public sentiment remained cold following the apology announcement.
Key Information to Verify
The core point of criticism was the absence of specific references to his great-grandfather's pro-Japanese activities in the apology. While the Pro-Japanese Collaborators Encyclopedia editorial team identified Hae-Young's great-grandfather as a collaborator, the apology lacked explicit acknowledgment.
The omission of mention of his 'great-grandfather from Surokdo' was criticized. This refers to the fact that while the apology mentioned 'great-grandfather,' it omitted specific reference to his 'great-grandfather from Surokdo,' drawing criticism.
The 200,000 follower increase after the apology was analyzed as a noise marketing effect. However, public anger persisted, with sentiment remaining cold.
Frequently Asked Questions
Did Hae-Young's handwritten apology include specific references to his great-grandfather's pro-Japanese activities?
No, the apology used general terms like 'family history' without specific mention of his great-grandfather identified as a collaborator. This omission drew criticism.
Where was the apology posted and deleted?
Hae-Young posted the apology on Chinese social media before deleting it abruptly on August 14, 2026. This appears to be due to criticism over the use of vague terms like 'family history' instead of specific references to pro-Japanese activities.
What was the effect of the follower increase after the apology?
Hae-Young's follower count increased by 200,000 following the apology announcement. This was analyzed as a noise marketing effect. However, public anger persisted, and sentiment remained cold.
You can view similar articles on this topic in one place.
View Related ArticlesFAQ
Did Hae-Young's handwritten apology include specific references to his great-grandfather's pro-Japanese activities?
No, the apology used general terms like 'family history' without specific mention of his great-grandfather identified as a collaborator. This omission drew criticism.
Where was the apology posted and deleted?
Hae-Young posted the apology on Chinese social media before deleting it abruptly on August 14, 2026. This appears to be due to criticism over the use of vague terms like 'family history' instead of specific references to pro-Japanese activities.
What was the effect of the follower increase after the apology?
Hae-Young's follower count increased by 200,000 following the apology announcement. This was analyzed as a noise marketing effect. However, public anger persisted, and sentiment remained cold.
Korean Source
This article is an English localization of a Korean-language report from BlogScore. Original: 하영 자필 사과가 왜 논란이 되었는지, 단계별로 정리