KOSUNI KOREA
Korean News in English
Technology

Understanding Legal Risks When Extracting Music from YouTube

Published October 18, 2026 · 1 views
Understanding Legal Risks When Extracting Music from YouTube

Legal Risks of Extracting Music from YouTube

Extracting music from YouTube or creating AI cover songs can lead to legal disputes over copyright infringement. Similar to cases involving Google and Kakao Melon, government agencies have imposed fines for issues like inadequate paid service procedures or unauthorized resale of music. On January 22, 2020, the Korea Communications Commission (KCC) fined Google ₩432 million and ordered improvements to its paid subscription process, citing concerns over 'bundling' in YouTube Premium services that separately offer YouTube Music. Additionally, Kakao Melon held a market share of 38.6% in January 2021 but dropped to 32.8% by 2022, while YouTube Music's share rose to 9.8%.

유튜브 음원 추출 시 주의해야 할 법적 문제 점검 설명 이미지

Copyright Issues with AI Cover Songs

Creating cover songs using AI that modify existing tracks can lead to legal disputes due to gaps in copyright regulations. In November 2024, Civic News reported a surge in popularity of AI cover songs, which have been featured on Netflix's 'New Singer Joo Jung-seok' and KBS's 'Syncro You.' Relatedly, in November 2023, The Korea Daily published an article titled '[HI★Focus] Are AI Cover Songs Really Problem-Free?' raising copyright concerns. In February 2024, Computer World followed up with a deep dive titled '[Focus] Flood of AI Cover Songs…Need for Copyright Regulations.' Some YouTubers have been reported to profit by illegally using others' content via AI, making it urgent to address copyright infringement issues.

Changes in YouTube Music Market Share

As of 2022, YouTube Music recorded a monthly active user (MAU) count of 7.24 million, securing the top market share among music streaming services. This growth is attributed to Google's strategy of offering YouTube Music separately within YouTube Premium. Meanwhile, Kakao Melon's market share fell from 38.6% in 2021 to 32.8% in 2022, while YouTube Music's share reached 9.8%, reflecting a significant shift in the market structure. Kakao Melon was also fined ₩98 million by the KCC in December 2021 after failing to adequately inform users about mid-term cancellation options for its subscription service, following allegations of music resale by Park Kyung.

Penalties for Google and Kakao Melon

The KCC imposed a ₩432 million fine on Google and ordered improvements to its paid subscription process. Google argued that the fine was excessive compared to its revenue of approximately ₩27.9 billion, but the KCC explained it applied relevant laws for fixed penalties. Kakao Melon was fined ₩98 million for not sufficiently informing users about mid-term cancellation options when selling its music-only subscription service. On April 16, 2025, Google submitted a corrective action plan related to YouTube Premium to the Fair Trade Commission and requested approval.

Key Considerations When Extracting YouTube Music

Most online guides for downloading music from YouTube are free app recommendations that often carry copyright infringement risks. To avoid legal issues, using official services is strongly recommended. In February 2023, Unicorn Factory reported on cases where YouTubers use AI to steal others' content for profit, noting such actions could violate Article 27 of the Copyright Act and music resale practices under Article 26 of the Music Industry Promotion Act.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are AI cover songs legally compliant?

Legal disputes are possible due to gaps in copyright regulations. Specific verification is required.

What's the difference in market share between YouTube Music and Kakao Melon?

As of 2022, YouTube Music held a 9.8% market share while Kakao Melon dropped to 32.8%.

Why was Google fined?

The fine stemmed from concerns over 'bundling' in YouTube Premium services that separately offer YouTube Music.

Read More Related Articles

You can explore more articles on this topic in one place.

View Related Articles

FAQ

Are AI cover songs legally compliant?

Legal disputes are possible due to gaps in copyright regulations. Specific verification is required.

What's the difference in market share between YouTube Music and Kakao Melon?

As of 2022, YouTube Music held a 9.8% market share while Kakao Melon dropped to 32.8%.

Why was Google fined?

The fine stemmed from concerns over 'bundling' in YouTube Premium services that separately offer YouTube Music.

Korean Source

This article is an English localization of a Korean-language report from BlogScore. Original: 유튜브 음원 추출 시 주의해야 할 법적 문제 점검