KOSUNI KOREA
Korean News in English
News

Supreme Court Justice Succession: Selection Process and Key Criteria Revealed

Published October 10, 2026 · 1 views
Supreme Court Justice Succession: Selection Process and Key Criteria Revealed

대법관 후임 후보 공식 발표: 선정 과정과 주요 기준은?

Supreme Court Succession Process Begins

The Supreme Court has initiated the selection process for a successor to Justice Lee Heung-gu, who is set to retire in September. With the nomination of Justice No Tae-ak delayed, the court remains in a 13-member structure, and it is reported that four candidates have been narrowed down for the position.

Controversy Over 'Fortress' Composition and Diversity

The selection process has drawn attention to a so-called 'fortress' composition of justices—predominantly male, in their 50s, with judicial backgrounds and Seoul National University law school ties. The four candidates for Justice Lee's successor are Kim Moon-gwan, Kim Sung-su, Kim Ye-young, and Kim Jung-joong. Meanwhile, the vacancy following Justice No Tae-ak's retirement has persisted due to delayed nominations.

Among 28 candidates under review, only one is non-judicial in background, and women account for just two of the nominees, raising concerns about a lack of diversity in gender and professional backgrounds. This trend aligns with recent declines in public approval ratings for female judicial candidates nominated to the Supreme Court.

Succession Process Timeline and Reporting

The Supreme Court began nominating candidates for Justice Lee's successor on May 22, and publicly announced a list of 28 candidates on June 19. On August 4, it narrowed down the four finalists: Kim Moon-gwan, Kim Sung-su, Kim Ye-young, and Kim Jung-joong.

Justice No Tae-ak's successor selection process started on November 14, 2025, but nominations have been delayed, leaving a vacancy. It is currently expected that the nomination will be completed by March of next year.

Return to the '14-Member System'?

The Supreme Court is operating with a 13-member structure following Justice Lee's retirement. Once the successor is confirmed, it is likely to return to its traditional 14-member system, which could strengthen judicial independence.

Some media outlets have suggested that increasing the number of justices and strengthening presidential appointment powers should be considered alongside discussions about expanding the court. While there has been speculation about simultaneously nominating successors for both Justice Lee and Justice No Tae-ak, no concrete plans have been announced as of yet.

대법관 후임 후보 공식 발표: 선정 과정과 주요 기준은?

Characteristics of the Justice Selection Process

The possibility of including a candidate with pro-labor views has been raised. This reflects growing expectations that the Supreme Court may issue more flexible rulings in labor-related cases.

The selection process narrowed down 28 candidates to four, indicating the court's cautious approach. However, the continued 'fortress' structure suggests limited optimism for significant change.

Key Dates for Justice Succession

The Supreme Court officially announced the start of the succession process for Justice Lee on May 18, 2026, began nominations on May 22, and revealed the list of 28 candidates on June 19.

On August 4, 2026, the four finalists—Kim Moon-gwan, Kim Sung-su, Kim Ye-young, and Kim Jung-joong—were announced. Meanwhile, Justice No Tae-ak's successor selection process began on November 14, 2025, but nominations have been delayed, leaving a vacancy to date.

Supreme Court Composition and Reporting

The 'fortress' structure of the Supreme Court has drawn criticism for its reliance on male justices in their 50s with judicial backgrounds and Seoul National University law school ties. With only two women among the candidates and just one non-judicial candidate, concerns about lack of diversity persist.

Justice Lee's retirement has maintained the court's 13-member structure, a situation resulting from years without expansion. The delay in nominating Justice No Tae-ak's successor is believed to reflect internal personnel management issues within the court.

Diversity Concerns and Female Judicial Candidates

Public approval ratings for female judicial candidates have been declining, suggesting insufficient efforts by the Supreme Court to promote gender diversity. The court has an opportunity to return to a 14-member structure in 2026, which could lead to some changes if both succession processes are completed.

Ongoing Debates on Judicial Appointments

The 'fortress' composition and lack of diversity have been re-emphasized during the selection process. Some argue that expanding the court's membership would help diversify its structure, though no concrete policy changes have occurred yet.

There has also been speculation about simultaneously nominating successors for both Justice Lee and Justice No Tae-ak, but this remains unconfirmed as of now.

Key Information to Verify

Important points to monitor include when the succession process will be completed, when the candidate list will be officially announced, and the specific legal procedures involved in nominating a successor. Whether Justice Lee's appointment will contribute to restoring the 14-member system is also a key factor.

Frequently Asked Questions

When will the Supreme Court complete its succession process? The court began the selection process for Justice Lee on May 18, 2026, and announced four candidates on August 4. The exact appointment date has not yet been disclosed.

What is the 'fortress' structure of the Supreme Court? The term refers to a composition dominated by male justices in their 50s with judicial backgrounds and Seoul National University law school ties. This lack of diversity has recently sparked debate.

On what criteria does the court select candidates? Selection considers factors such as legal background, experience, gender, and professional history, with most nominees coming from judicial careers and Seoul National University. However, recent low representation of women and non-judicial backgrounds has raised concerns about diversity.

Frequently Asked Questions

The Supreme Court is selecting a successor for Justice Lee Heung-gu while the nomination for Justice No Tae-ak's successor remains delayed, maintaining the 13-member structure. The four candidates—Kim Moon-gwan, Kim Sung-su, Kim Ye-young, and Kim Jung-joong—are under consideration, with ongoing concerns about low diversity in gender and professional backgrounds. Further updates on potential structural changes to the court are expected.

Read More Related Articles

You can view similar articles all at once.

View Related Articles

FAQ

When will the Supreme Court complete its succession process?

The court began the selection process for Justice Lee on May 18, 2026, and announced four candidates on August 4. The exact appointment date has not yet been disclosed.

What is the 'fortress' structure of the Supreme Court?

The term refers to a composition dominated by male justices in their 50s with judicial backgrounds and Seoul National University law school ties. This lack of diversity has recently sparked debate.

On what criteria does the court select candidates?

Selection considers factors such as legal background, experience, gender, and professional history, with most nominees coming from judicial careers and Seoul National University. However, recent low representation of women and non-judicial backgrounds has raised concerns about diversity.

Korean Source

This article is an English localization of a Korean-language report from BlogScore. Original: 대법관 후임 후보 공식 발표: 선정 과정과 주요 기준은?