KOSUNI KOREA
Korean News in English
Business

Securities Firms' Fee Controversy: Why Brokerages Are Furious Over a 1 Trillion Won Dispute

Published September 22, 2026 · 3 views
Securities Firms' Fee Controversy: Why Brokerages Are Furious Over a 1 Trillion Won Dispute

The Core of the Securities Fee Controversy: Retail Investor Losses vs Brokerage Profits

Brokerage firms have come under scrutiny after it was confirmed they earned over 1 trillion won in overseas stock trading fees, widening the gap between retail investors' losses and brokerage profits. According to reports, Mirae Asset Securities recorded over 1 trillion won in net profit for two consecutive quarters, setting a new industry record. Overseas stock trading fees reached an all-time high of 2 trillion won, with retail investors losing half their investments while brokerages reaped massive profits.

The surge in brokerage fee revenue coincided with increased overseas stock trading activity and a rise in investor loans. Hankyoreh reported that interest income from such loans reached 4.4 trillion won annually due to the rapid growth of 'borrowed investment' (or 'debt investing'). Maeil Business Daily noted that securities firms' net profit for Q1 hit a record high of 4.3 trillion won, while IT Chosun highlighted industry competition over lowering fees amid claims that brokerages earned 10 trillion won.

The core controversy lies in brokerage firms earning over 1 trillion won in overseas stock trading fees despite retail investors' net selling. Kyobo Securities faced backlash for charging customers 10 times the standard fee—a case dubbed 'overcharging'—which the Financial Supervisory Service (FSS) failed to manage. The National Pension Service has also been criticized for ignoring corporate bond demand forecasts, contributing to price distortions.

Securities Firms' Q1 Performance and Overseas Stock Fee Trends

Securities firms reported record-high net profits of 4.3 trillion won in Q1. Maeil Business Daily explained this was due to a bull market, with overseas stock-related fees reaching 1 trillion won in the second quarter. Mirae Asset Securities achieved over 1 trillion won in net profit for two consecutive quarters.

The report stating overseas stock fees reached a record high of 1 trillion won was published on August 17, 2026. V.daum.net analyzed that increased trading activity among retail investors led to higher fees, reflecting the situation where individual investors suffered half their losses while brokerages earned significant profits.

Some reports claim brokerage fee revenue reached 16 trillion won in total, including both domestic and overseas stock transactions. This figure highlights the role of securities firms as a cash cow for the financial industry. Interest income from investor loans, at 4.4 trillion won annually, is largely attributed to the rapid growth of 'borrowed investment'.

Kyobo Securities Overcharging Controversy

The controversy over Kyobo Securities charging customers ten times the standard fee was reported on October 5, 2018. The Financial Supervisory Service (FSS) failed to manage this case, highlighting inadequate fee-setting standards among brokerages.

Additionally, the National Pension Service has been criticized for ignoring corporate bond demand forecasts since February 26, 2025, being identified as a key factor in price distortions. This behavior is seen as undermining market fairness and raising concerns about investor protection.

Top 10 securities firms saw their Q1 operating profits more than double due to the 'dead market' (a period of low trading activity) in domestic markets, according to a report published on May 17, 2026. This growth is attributed to diversified revenue streams through investor loans and fee income.

Shifts in Brokerage Revenue Structure Amid Market Boom

Securities firms' Q1 net profit reached a record high of 43 trillion won due to market boom, marking significant growth compared to previous years. Overseas stock trading expansion was the main driver behind increased fee revenue.

Brokerages are acting as cash cows for financial institutions through interest and fee income. Overseas stock-related fees hit 1 trillion won in Q2, growing alongside active trading by retail investors.

Total brokerage fee revenue of 16 trillion won is reported to include both domestic and overseas transactions, directly reflecting the market boom. Interest income from investor loans reached 4.4 trillion won annually due to increased 'borrowed investment' activity.

Intensifying Competition for Lowest Fees in Industry

IT Chosun reported that amid the controversy over brokerages earning 10 trillion won, the industry is intensifying competition to offer the lowest fees. This strategy aims to attract customers and diversify revenue streams.

The surge in brokerage fee income has raised calls for stronger regulation regarding excessive fees. Kyobo Securities' case exemplifies how some firms have overcharged clients, a problem attributed to insufficient oversight by the FSS.

Public criticism of the National Pension Service's failure to participate in corporate bond demand forecasts has also highlighted concerns about market fairness. This behavior is seen as undermining investor protection and prompting calls for additional regulatory measures from the government and FSS.

Key Points to Verify

The most critical point in this fee controversy is whether the '1 trillion won' figure refers solely to overseas stock trading fees or includes all brokerage fees. Reports indicate that Mirae Asset Securities' two consecutive quarters of over 1 trillion won in net profit were recorded from overseas stock trading fees, reflecting a contrast between retail investors' losses and brokerages' gains.

The Kyobo Securities case exposed regulatory gaps, as the FSS failed to manage fee overcharging. This highlights unclear fee-setting standards among brokerages and suggests a need for stronger regulation in the future.

Public criticism of the National Pension Service's disregard for corporate bond demand forecasts points to potential market fairness issues. This behavior is seen as undermining investor protection, prompting calls for government and FSS intervention.

증권사 수수료 1조 논란, 왜 증권사들이 분노했는지 설명 이미지

Frequently Asked Questions

Did securities firms earn 1 trillion won from overseas stock trading fees?

Yes. According to reports, Mirae Asset Securities recorded over 1 trillion won in net profit for two consecutive quarters, setting an industry record. Overseas stock trading fees reached a record high of 2 trillion won, contrasting with retail investors' significant losses.

How was the Kyobo Securities fee overcharging controversy handled?

On October 5, 2018, reports revealed that Kyobo Securities charged customers ten times the standard fee—a case labeled 'overcharging'—but the Financial Supervisory Service (FSS) failed to manage it. This highlighted inadequate fee-setting standards among brokerages.

Why did the National Pension Service ignore corporate bond demand forecasts?

According to a report published on February 26, 2025, the National Pension Service ignored corporate bond demand forecasts, being identified as a key factor in price distortions. This behavior is seen as undermining market fairness and prompting calls for additional regulatory measures.

Frequently Asked Questions

The surge in securities firms' fee revenue amid market boom has sparked debate about whether it reflects positive growth or exposes regulatory gaps. Mirae Asset Securities' record two-quarter profit of over 1 trillion won in overseas stock fees highlights the industry's achievement, while retail investors' losses raise concerns about fairness.

Controversies involving Kyobo Securities and the National Pension Service underscore the need for stronger regulation to protect investors. The intensifying competition for lowest fees suggests evolving industry dynamics, signaling potential shifts in competitive strategies.

While market boom-driven revenue growth is positive, considering retail investor losses, government and FSS must strengthen regulations. Clearer fee-setting standards and fair market operations by entities like the National Pension Service are essential for protecting investors.

Read More Related Articles

Explore similar articles on this topic in one place.

View Related Articles

FAQ

Did securities firms earn 1 trillion won from overseas stock trading fees?

Yes. According to reports, Mirae Asset Securities recorded over 1 trillion won in net profit for two consecutive quarters, setting an industry record. Overseas stock trading fees reached a record high of 2 trillion won, contrasting with retail investors' significant losses.

How was the Kyobo Securities fee overcharging controversy handled?

On October 5, 2018, reports revealed that Kyobo Securities charged customers ten times the standard fee—a case labeled 'overcharging'—but the Financial Supervisory Service (FSS) failed to manage it. This highlighted inadequate fee-setting standards among brokerages.

Why did the National Pension Service ignore corporate bond demand forecasts?

According to a report published on February 26, 2025, the National Pension Service ignored corporate bond demand forecasts, being identified as a key factor in price distortions. This behavior is seen as undermining market fairness and prompting calls for additional regulatory measures.

Korean Source

This article is an English localization of a Korean-language report from BlogScore. Original: 증권사 수수료 1조 논란, 왜 증권사들이 분노했는지