Samsung Securities' Ghost Stock Dividend Payment Failure: Solutions and Insights
The Nature of the Ghost Stock Dividend Error
The 'ghost stock' dividend error at Samsung Securities resulted in an 18 billion won loss for institutions like the National Pension Service, leading to a Supreme Court ruling ordering Samsung Securities to compensate. This case concluded after seven years of litigation.
The core issue was mistakenly processing '1000 won' as '1000 shares,' which led employees to sell stocks illegally. The incident first came to light in a 2018 April 9 report titled 'Samsung Securities’ Absurd Dividend Mistake of 112 Trillion Won.' The employees involved received suspended sentences and fines for selling the ghost stocks.
Specific Details of the Ghost Stock Incident
In April 2018, Samsung Securities mistakenly processed '1000 won' as '1000 shares,' causing a loss to the National Pension Service. Sixteen employees were investigated for selling ghost stocks, with one reportedly selling 1 million shares of ghost stock.
According to a Yonhap News report on April 9, 2018, Samsung Securities had made an erroneous dividend payment totaling 112 trillion won due to the ghost stock issue. The Supreme Court ruled on August 12, 2026, that Samsung Securities must compensate the National Pension Service with 18 billion won.
Employees were sentenced to suspended terms and fines for illegally selling ghost stocks, a ruling finalized on March 31, 2022. This case exposed weaknesses in Samsung Securities' internal control systems.
The use of blockchain technology has been proposed as a solution to prevent such errors, with The Seoul Times reporting that blockchain could block 'fat fingers'—a term for accidental large trades due to input errors.

Significance of the Supreme Court Ruling and Internal Control Issues
The Supreme Court's ruling on August 12, 2026, ordering Samsung Securities to pay 18 billion won in compensation to the National Pension Service concluded a seven-year legal battle. While the second court ruled that Samsung Securities should pay half the damages (9 billion won), the Supreme Court ordered full compensation of 18 billion won.
The internal control issues at Samsung Securities became evident during the ghost stock error incident. The case, where employees sold 'ghost stocks,' highlighted a failure in the company's internal audit system and led to a decline in trust.
The lawsuit between the National Pension Service and Samsung Securities began in 2018 and concluded with the Supreme Court ruling in 2026, serving as a serious warning about Samsung Group's internal management systems.
Cause of the Ghost Stock Error and Steps to Address Dividend Payment Failures
The ghost stock error occurred due to mistakenly processing '1000 won' as '1000 shares,' stemming from weaknesses in Samsung Securities' internal control system. Employees exploited this mistake by selling stocks, resulting in suspended sentences and fines.
If you experience a dividend payment failure, follow these steps: First, contact Samsung Securities immediately to verify and correct the error. Second, keep evidence for potential legal action. Third, report to investor protection agencies for additional support.
As a result of this incident, Samsung Securities must pay 18 billion won in compensation to the National Pension Service. The company needs to improve internal controls and strengthen employee training to prevent recurrence.
Key Information and News Coverage
The main points to verify about the ghost stock dividend error are: First, a report on April 9, 2018, stated that Samsung Securities made an erroneous dividend payment of 112 trillion won. Second, the Supreme Court ruled on August 12, 2026, that Samsung Securities must pay 18 billion won in compensation.
The ghost stock incident began with a April 9, 2018 report titled 'Samsung Securities’ Absurd Dividend Mistake of 112 Trillion Won,' followed by the March 31, 2022 ruling on suspended sentences and fines for employees. The final Supreme Court decision was issued on August 12, 2026.
The proposed solution involving blockchain technology to address ghost stock issues was highlighted in a The Seoul Times report, emphasizing its potential to prevent 'fat fingers' errors.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the key ruling of the Supreme Court regarding Samsung Securities’ compensation for the National Pension Service?
The Supreme Court ordered Samsung Securities to pay 18 billion won in compensation. This was finalized after seven years of litigation, with the second court initially ordering half (9 billion won), but the Supreme Court requiring full payment.
What caused the ghost stock error at Samsung Securities?
The error occurred when '1000 won' was mistakenly processed as '1000 shares,' due to weaknesses in Samsung Securities' internal control system. Employees exploited this mistake, resulting in suspended sentences and fines.
What should investors do if they fail to receive dividends?
Contact Samsung Securities immediately to verify and correct the error. Keep evidence for potential legal action, and report to investor protection agencies for additional support.
Frequently Asked Questions
The ghost stock dividend error at Samsung Securities, which caused financial losses for the National Pension Service, resulted in a Supreme Court ruling ordering 18 billion won in compensation. This case highlighted weaknesses in internal controls and employee ethics, serving as an important lesson for improving management systems and investor protection.
Proposed solutions like blockchain technology aim to prevent such errors by addressing 'fat fingers'—a common mistake in trading due to input errors. The Supreme Court ruling has become a significant milestone for Samsung Securities to improve its internal management and prevent similar incidents in the future.
This case underscores the importance of robust internal control systems and employee training, emphasizing the need for systematic measures to protect investors. Samsung Securities' experience serves as a warning across the financial industry about the necessity of improving internal management and restoring investor trust.
You can find similar articles in one place.
View Related ArticlesFAQ
What is the key ruling of the Supreme Court regarding Samsung Securities’ compensation for the National Pension Service?
The Supreme Court ordered Samsung Securities to pay 18 billion won in compensation. This was finalized after seven years of litigation, with the second court initially ordering half (9 billion won), but the Supreme Court requiring full payment.
What caused the ghost stock error at Samsung Securities?
The error occurred when '1000 won' was mistakenly processed as '1000 shares,' due to weaknesses in Samsung Securities' internal control system. Employees exploited this mistake, resulting in suspended sentences and fines.
What should investors do if they fail to receive dividends?
Contact Samsung Securities immediately to verify and correct the error. Keep evidence for potential legal action, and report to investor protection agencies for additional support.
Korean Source
This article is an English localization of a Korean-language report from BlogScore. Original: 삼성증권 유령주식 배당금 수령 실패 시 해결 방법