Samsung Securities' Ghost Stock Dividend Incident: Victim Recruitment and Compensation Process



Key Points Summary
The Samsung Securities ghost stock dividend incident occurred on April 30, 2018, due to inadequate internal controls that resulted in the creation of phantom stocks, causing damage to the National Pension Service. As a result, the National Pension Service claimed 29.9 billion won from Samsung Securities, but the Supreme Court ruled for an 18 billion won settlement after seven years of legal proceedings. Notably, it was confirmed that 16 employees at Samsung Securities sold phantom stocks, with some selling up to 35 billion won worth of shares.
Incident Background and Timeline
The ghost stock dividend incident resulted from a combination of internal system errors and employee misconduct, first discovered on April 30, 2018. At the time, Samsung Securities faced an issue where phantom stocks were generated in their trading system, leading to improper dividend payments. This was attributed to inadequate internal controls, with employees suspected of selling phantom stocks for personal gain. In particular, some employees reportedly sold up to 35 billion won worth of shares, highlighting a lack of proper management oversight within Samsung Securities. After the incident occurred on April 30, 2018, Samsung Securities immediately began an internal investigation, but it took time to determine the exact scale and identify those responsible.
Legal Proceedings and Supreme Court Ruling
The National Pension Service initiated a claim for damages against Samsung Securities following the incident in 2018, though legal proceedings were prolonged. On August 12, 2026, the Supreme Court delivered its final ruling, determining that Samsung Securities must compensate the National Pension Service with 1.8 billion won. This amount represents approximately 6% of the claimed 29.9 billion won, as the court considered the circumstances at the time of the incident and the extent of inadequate internal controls. The Supreme Court specifically criticized Samsung Securities' 'employee culling' practice in its ruling, emphasizing the need for improved internal controls. This serves as a lesson that companies should not overlook employee misconduct but establish thorough monitoring systems. After the August 12, 2026 Supreme Court ruling was confirmed, Samsung Securities began the compensation process for the National Pension Service, marking the conclusion of an eight-year case since its occurrence.
Comparison with Bithumb's Overpayment Case
The Samsung Securities ghost stock dividend incident shares similarities with a recent 60 trillion won overpayment case at Bithumb. Both incidents involved a combination of internal system flaws and employee misconduct leading to significant losses, with inadequate internal controls identified as the core cause. In the Bithumb case, funds were improperly credited to user accounts, whereas in Samsung Securities' case, the loss occurred through improper dividend payments on phantom stocks. While both cases highlight the need for improved corporate management oversight, they differ in that the Bithumb incident affected users directly with temporary fund losses in December 2023, while Samsung Securities' issue directly impacted the National Pension Service through dividend mispayments.
Current Victim Recruitment and Compensation Application Process
As part of its internal control improvements, Samsung Securities is currently conducting a compensation application process for investors who suffered losses due to the ghost stock dividend incident. Victims can submit their claims through Samsung Securities' website or customer service center. Notably, Samsung Securities has already provided compensation to investors who sold shares on the same day as the phantom stock sales, reflecting its proactive approach to victim protection since the early stages of the incident. The application process officially began after the Supreme Court's August 12, 2026 ruling, with Samsung Securities currently verifying victims and determining compensation amounts based on internal audit findings. Additionally, Samsung Securities has posted detailed guidance on its website to ensure investors can easily access the compensation procedures.
What Readers Should Know
1. The cause of the Samsung Securities ghost stock dividend incident was inadequate internal controls and employee misconduct, occurring on April 30, 2018.
2. According to the Supreme Court ruling, Samsung Securities must compensate the National Pension Service with 1.8 billion won, which is approximately 6% of the claimed 29.9 billion won.
3. The victim recruitment and compensation application process is currently underway, with applications possible through Samsung Securities' website or customer service center.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: How was the compensation determined for the ghost stock dividend incident?
A: The Supreme Court ruled that Samsung Securities must compensate 1.8 billion won to the National Pension Service, considering inadequate internal controls and employee misconduct. This amount is approximately 6% of the claimed 29.9 billion won.
Q: How can victims apply for compensation from the ghost stock dividend incident?
A: Victims can submit a compensation application through Samsung Securities' website or customer service center. Compensation has already been provided to investors who sold shares on the same day as the phantom stock sales.
Q: How is the Bithumb 60 trillion won overpayment case related to Samsung Securities' ghost stock incident?
A: Both cases involved significant losses due to internal system flaws and employee misconduct, highlighting inadequate corporate internal controls. However, while Bithumb's case resulted in improper funds being credited to user accounts, Samsung Securities' issue involved incorrect dividend payments on phantom stocks.
You can find similar articles all in one place.
View Related ArticlesFAQ
How was the compensation determined for the ghost stock dividend incident?
The Supreme Court ruled that Samsung Securities must compensate 1.8 billion won to the National Pension Service, considering inadequate internal controls and employee misconduct. This amount is approximately 6% of the claimed 29.9 billion won.
How can victims apply for compensation from the ghost stock dividend incident?
Victims can submit a compensation application through Samsung Securities' website or customer service center. Compensation has already been provided to investors who sold shares on the same day as the phantom stock sales.
How is the Bithumb 60 trillion won overpayment case related to Samsung Securities' ghost stock incident?
Both cases involved significant losses due to internal system flaws and employee misconduct, highlighting inadequate corporate internal controls. However, while Bithumb's case resulted in improper funds being credited to user accounts, Samsung Securities' issue involved incorrect dividend payments on phantom stocks.
Korean Source
This article is an English localization of a Korean-language report from BlogScore. Original: 삼성증권 유령주식 배당 사고 피해자 모집 및 보상 신청 절차