Samsung Securities' Ghost Stock Dividend Incident: Compensation Claim Process
Overview of Samsung Securities' Ghost Stock Incident
South Korea's Samsung Securities faced a landmark court ruling in 2018, ordering the company to compensate 1.8 billion won to the National Pension Service due to an error in dividend distribution involving 'ghost stocks.' The case was analyzed as stemming from inadequate internal controls and moral lapses within the company. CEO Koo Jeong-hoon apologized for the incident, expressing shame and regret. The legal dispute lasted eight years, with the court ruling that Samsung Securities must cover 50% of investor losses.
Scale and Timeline of the Ghost Stock Incident
The ghost stock dividend error first came to light in April 2018, when it was revealed that some employees had sold 'ghost stocks.' Notably, one employee reportedly sold 1 million shares for a profit of 35 billion won. The incident involved an overpayment of dividends amounting to 11.2 trillion won, attributed to poor internal controls and moral lapses.
Yonhap News Agency reported on April 9, 2018, that Samsung Securities had experienced a ghost stock dividend error involving 11.2 trillion won. The following day, vop.co.kr published an article titled 'Samsung Securities Ghost Stock Incident Reaches Crisis Point.' In October 2019, it was reported that one employee had earned profits worth 35 billion won through the sale of ghost stocks.
Incident Background
The ghost stock dividend error occurred due to a system mistake where dividends were processed as 1,000 won for 1,000 shares. This was analyzed as a result of a technical flaw and highlighted severe deficiencies in internal controls. After the incident, Samsung Securities initiated organizational reforms to address these issues.
On April 9, 2018, CEO Koo Jeong-hoon apologized for the ghost stock dividend error, expressing shame and regret. This apology preceded the Supreme Court ruling and coincided with media coverage of the growing controversy.
On September 27, 2021, Law News reported that Samsung Securities had been ordered to compensate investors for 50% of their losses following an eight-year legal battle. The court cited inadequate internal controls as a key factor in its ruling.
Cause Analysis
The primary causes of the Samsung Securities ghost stock incident were inadequate internal control systems and moral lapses by employees. This was not merely a technical error but a systemic issue within the organization, prompting Samsung Securities to implement organizational reforms afterward.
The incident occurred in 2018 and bore similarities to the Bithumb 'ghost Bitcoin' incident that emerged eight years later. Both cases highlighted recurring risks of system failures due to poor internal controls.
Samsung Securities estimated potential losses from the ghost stock dividend error at 43 billion won, though this represented only a fraction of the total overpayment of 11.2 trillion won. The case was attributed to both inadequate internal controls and moral lapses by employees. Similar patterns were observed in Bithumb's 'ghost Bitcoin' incident, which was reported on February 8, 2026.
Company Response and Safety Measures
After the ghost stock incident, Samsung Securities initiated organizational reforms to address internal control weaknesses. This included strengthening internal control systems and enhancing employee training programs.
The scale of the error reached 11.2 trillion won, leading to a court ruling that Samsung Securities must compensate half of investor losses. However, specific details on how to apply for compensation were not provided in available materials. This reflects a lack of clear information about the claims process.
Following the Supreme Court ruling, Samsung Securities was required to pay 1.8 billion won to the National Pension Service as part of the settlement. This case became a notable example of liability resulting from internal control failures within the company.
A report published on February 8, 2026, compared Bithumb's 'ghost Bitcoin' incident with Samsung Securities' ghost stock case, suggesting that similar systemic issues could recur due to insufficient internal controls.
Key Information to Verify
The article does not specify how to apply for compensation related to the Samsung Securities ghost stock dividend error. This indicates a lack of clear information about the claims process. Further details needed include:
- Exact technical causes and system flaws behind the dividend error
- Specific internal control improvement plans implemented by Samsung Securities
- Additional measures taken by Samsung Securities following similar incidents
While Samsung Securities estimated potential losses at 43 billion won, this figure represents a small portion of the total overpayment of 11.2 trillion won. The Supreme Court ruled that Samsung Securities must compensate the National Pension Service with 1.8 billion won.
CEO Koo Jeong-hoon's apology was reported as expressing shame and regret for the ghost stock dividend error, indicating an early acknowledgment of responsibility by the company.
The legal dispute lasted eight years, with the court ruling that Samsung Securities must cover 50% of investor losses due to inadequate internal controls. This case is recorded as a significant example where the company accepted responsibility for its internal control system shortcomings.

Frequently Asked Questions
What caused Samsung Securities' ghost stock incident?
The ghost stock dividend error occurred due to a technical mistake where dividends were processed as 1,000 won for 1,000 shares. The case was analyzed as stemming from inadequate internal controls and moral lapses within the company.
What penalties did Samsung Securities face following the incident?
Following a Supreme Court ruling, Samsung Securities must compensate 1.8 billion won to the National Pension Service and cover 50% of investor losses. The legal dispute lasted eight years.
Have similar incidents occurred at other companies?
Yes, Bithumb's 'ghost Bitcoin' incident in 2026 showed similar systemic issues related to internal control failures. This was reported on February 8, 2026, highlighting recurring risks of system flaws due to poor internal controls.
FAQ
What caused Samsung Securities' ghost stock incident?
The ghost stock dividend error occurred due to a technical mistake where dividends were processed as 1,000 won for 1,000 shares. The case was analyzed as stemming from inadequate internal controls and moral lapses within the company.
What penalties did Samsung Securities face following the incident?
Following a Supreme Court ruling, Samsung Securities must compensate 1.8 billion won to the National Pension Service and cover 50% of investor losses. The legal dispute lasted eight years.
Have similar incidents occurred at other companies?
Yes, Bithumb's 'ghost Bitcoin' incident in 2026 showed similar systemic issues related to internal control failures. This was reported on February 8, 2026, highlighting recurring risks of system flaws due to poor internal controls.
Korean Source
This article is an English localization of a Korean-language report from BlogScore. Original: 삼성증권 유령주식 배당 사고 보상 신청 방법