Samsung Securities' Ghost Stock Dividend Error: Causes and Response
Overview of Samsung Securities' Ghost Stock Dividend Error Incident
The ghost stock dividend error at Samsung Securities occurred on April 9, 2018, due to an employee's mistake, causing a significant stock price crash. The incident exposed vulnerabilities in the brokerage's internal systems and led to litigation with the National Pension Service, resulting in a final court ruling ordering ₩180 million in compensation.
Key Facts of the Ghost Stock Dividend Error Incident
An employee error at Samsung Securities resulted in dividend payments being issued for 'ghost stocks,' causing an immediate stock price drop. For 37 minutes after the incident, the system malfunctioned, triggering a trading halt.
A April 9, 2018 Yonhap News report described Samsung Securities' 'absurd dividend error of 11.2 trillion won,' which caused the stock crash. The cause was erroneous dividend payments for stocks that did not actually exist.
South Korea's National Pension Service sued Samsung Securities over the incident, and a Supreme Court ruling determined Samsung must compensate ₩180 million, covering 50% of the stock price crash losses. The lawsuit lasted approximately 7-8 years, beginning in September 2021.
Incident Timeline and Media Coverage
On April 9, 2018, a Samsung Securities employee made an error during dividend processing, leading to payments for non-existent 'ghost stocks' and a stock price crash. The system malfunctioned for 37 minutes, resulting in a trading halt.
On April 16, 2018, the Daily Economic News reported on the 'ghost stock' shock at Samsung Securities, mentioning then-CEO Jang Seok-hoon and Koo Jeong-hoon. The incident's scale and impact were widely covered.
The lawsuit related to the ghost stock dividend error began on September 26, 2021, when the National Pension Service filed a claim for damages against Samsung Securities. On September 4, 2024, the Hankyoreh reported that Samsung Securities had been ordered to pay ₩180 million in compensation.
On August 12, 2026, MBC News and News1 reported that the Supreme Court ruled Samsung Securities must pay ₩180 million in damages. The company's CEO, Koo Jeong-hoon, stated he would respect the court ruling.
Investigation into the Cause of the Ghost Stock Dividend Error
The error was attributed to insufficient internal control procedures within Samsung Securities' stock trading system. As a securities firm, Samsung should have processed cash and stock dividends through the Depository Receipts Settlement Corporation but made an error due to a system flaw.
A Yonhap News report on April 9, 2018, described Samsung Securities' 'absurd dividend error of 11.2 trillion won,' which was confirmed as resulting from incorrect processing of dividends for ghost stocks.
Information about the specific roles and responsibilities of current and former CEOs Jang Seok-hoon and Koo Jeong-hoon during the incident is limited. Koo Jeong-hoon was reported as former CEO on May 16, 2018, while Jang Seok-hoon became CEO on November 3, 2021.
On April 10, 2018, Samsung Securities issued an internal notice regarding the ghost stock issue and implemented a trading halt to prevent further price drops due to system issues.
Samsung Securities' Response and Safety Measures
Following the incident, Samsung Securities strengthened its internal control systems and implemented employee training programs to prevent future errors. However, these measures were seen as short-term fixes rather than long-term safety solutions.
Per the Supreme Court ruling, Samsung Securities must compensate the National Pension Service ₩180 million, which includes 50% of the stock price crash losses. The main issue was that the system malfunctioned for 37 minutes after the incident, triggering a trading halt.
Ceo Koo Jeong-hoon stated Samsung would respect the court ruling. He was reported as former CEO on May 16, 2018; Jang Seok-hoon became current CEO and Chairman on November 3, 2021.

Key Information to Verify
Details about the specific roles and responsibilities of Samsung Securities CEOs Jang Seok-hoon and Koo Jeong-hoon during the incident remain unclear. This information is important for understanding internal control system failures at the time.
The exact scale of stock price crash losses and calculation methods related to the ghost stock dividend error are still not fully clear, which was a key point of contention in the lawsuit between Samsung Securities and the National Pension Service.
Specific findings from investigations into Samsung Securities' internal system vulnerabilities have not been publicly disclosed. This information could be important for developing additional safety measures to prevent similar incidents.
Frequently Asked Questions
How did the ghost stock dividend error occur?
An employee mistake at Samsung Securities led to dividend payments being issued for non-existent 'ghost stocks,' causing a stock price crash. This was due to insufficient internal control procedures within the trading system.
How much must Samsung Securities compensate the National Pension Service?
Per the Supreme Court ruling, Samsung Securities must pay ₩180 million in compensation to the National Pension Service, which includes 50% of the stock price crash losses.
When did the ghost stock dividend error case conclude?
The case concluded on August 12, 2026, with a Supreme Court ruling ordering Samsung Securities to pay ₩180 million. The lawsuit began in September 2021 and lasted approximately 7-8 years.
Frequently Asked Questions
The ghost stock dividend error incident at Samsung Securities was confirmed as resulting from internal system vulnerabilities and employee error, causing a stock price crash on April 9, 2018. It led to litigation with the National Pension Service, culminating in a Supreme Court ruling ordering ₩180 million in compensation.
Following the incident, Samsung Securities strengthened its internal control systems and implemented employee training programs but these were seen as short-term fixes rather than comprehensive long-term solutions. The exact scale of stock price crash losses and calculation methods remain unclear, and specific findings from investigations into system vulnerabilities have not been publicly disclosed.
Details about the specific roles and responsibilities of CEOs Jang Seok-hoon and Koo Jeong-hoon during the incident are limited, which is important for understanding internal control failures at the time. This information could serve as a valuable lesson to prevent similar incidents in the future.
You can view more articles on this topic together.
View Related ArticlesFAQ
How did the ghost stock dividend error occur?
An employee mistake at Samsung Securities led to dividend payments being issued for non-existent 'ghost stocks,' causing a stock price crash. This was due to insufficient internal control procedures within the trading system.
How much must Samsung Securities compensate the National Pension Service?
Per the Supreme Court ruling, Samsung Securities must pay ₩180 million in compensation to the National Pension Service, which includes 50% of the stock price crash losses.
When did the ghost stock dividend error case conclude?
The case concluded on August 12, 2026, with a Supreme Court ruling ordering Samsung Securities to pay ₩180 million. The lawsuit began in September 2021 and lasted approximately 7-8 years.
Korean Source
This article is an English localization of a Korean-language report from BlogScore. Original: 삼성증권 유령주식 배당금 수령 실패 원인 및 대응