The Problem with Japan's Dokdo Sovereignty Claim in the Defense White Paper


Japan's Persistent Claim of Dokdo Sovereignty in Defense White Papers
Japan has consistently claimed Dokdo (Takeshima) as its territory in defense white papers for 13 consecutive years from 2014 to 2026, a claim that has been criticized as illegal under international law. The same content was repeated in the 2021 and 2024 defense white papers, including the 2025 children's defense white paper.
Historical Background of Dokdo Sovereignty Claim
Japan has maintained its claim that Dokdo belongs to Japan since 1905, but this is considered illegal under international law. Dokdo is recognized as Korea's exclusive territory, with documented evidence showing Korean government administration over the island in the early 20th century. Japan's claim lacks historical and legal basis.
Continued Sovereignty Claims in Japan's Defense White Papers
The first mention of Dokdo as Japanese territory appeared in Japan's defense white paper on August 5, 2014, and has been repeated annually since. On July 13, 2021, it explicitly stated 'Dokdo is Japanese land,' and on July 12, 2024, it continued to refer to Dokdo as 'Takeshima' for the 20th consecutive year. The 2025 children's defense white paper also included this claim.
Japan's sovereignty claim over Dokdo has been criticized as illegal under international law since 1905, with particular attention drawn to its repetition in the 2021 and 2024 defense white papers. The Japanese government continues to refer to Dokdo as 'Takeshima,' denying Korea's sovereignty.
Korean Government's Response
The Ministry of National Defense summoned Japan's military attaché on August 8, 2017, demanding the withdrawal of the Dokdo sovereignty claim. On July 14, 2020, it summoned Japan's chief consul to urge a withdrawal. These actions represent strong rebuttals to Japan's persistent claims in its defense white papers and have sparked international controversy.
Gyeongsangbuk-do Governor Lee Cheol-woo strongly condemned Japan's defense white paper for maintaining the Dokdo sovereignty claim until 2026, urging international condemnation of the Japanese government. This demonstrates Korea's central and local governments jointly responding to Japan's Dokdo sovereignty claims.
International Legal Issues
Japan's Dokdo sovereignty claim is illegal under international law. Since 1905, the Japanese government has not exercised jurisdiction over Dokdo, while the Korean government has administered it as its exclusive territory. Although Dokdo was previously debated at the International Court of Justice, Japan lacks legal grounds to support its claim.
Dokdo is Korea's historical territory with legitimate ownership based on historical facts and international law. Despite Japan continuing to refer to Dokdo as 'Takeshima,' this claim is not recognized internationally.
Japan's Dual Approach
The Japanese government emphasizes its Dokdo sovereignty while simultaneously highlighting cooperation with Korea, adopting a dual approach. For example, the defense white paper mentions Korea as an 'important neighboring country' and refers to improving cooperative relations alongside the Dokdo issue.
This dual approach appears to be part of Japan's diplomatic strategy to prevent international controversy over Dokdo while maintaining its sovereignty claim. However, it overlooks that Japan's claim is illegal under international law.

Analysis of the Causes Behind Dokdo Sovereignty Dispute
Japan's Dokdo sovereignty claim stems from historical misunderstandings and gaps in international law. Japan has maintained its claim since 1905, but this contradicts historical facts. The Korean government has exercised jurisdiction over Dokdo since the early 20th century, making Japan's claim illegal under international law.
The Dokdo issue is not merely a territorial dispute but concerns respecting historical truth and international law. By referring to Dokdo as 'Takeshima,' Japan denies Korea's historical ownership, which can only lead to international criticism.
Response and Safety Information
The Korean government has strongly rebutted Japan's defense white paper claims regarding Dokdo sovereignty, summoning key officials for discussions. In 2017 and 2020, it summoned Japan's military attaché and chief consul to demand withdrawal of the claim, which served as diplomatic pressure on the Japanese government.
The Dokdo Museum plays an important role in raising international awareness about the Dokdo sovereignty issue. However, recent reports have pointed out that there is no official basis for state funding of the Dokdo Museum, leading to criticism of Korea's policies related to Dokdo.
Key Information to Verify
To verify the Dokdo sovereignty issue, it's important to refer to Japan's official defense white papers and the Korean government's rebuttals. Japan has consistently referred to Dokdo as 'Takeshima' in its defense white papers from 2014 to 2026, a claim that is legally baseless under international law.
The continued assertion of Dokdo sovereignty in Japan's 2021 and 2024 defense white papers demonstrates the Japanese government's consistent stance, which has drawn strong opposition from both the Korean government and citizens. The inclusion of this claim in the 2025 children's defense white paper also shows Japan's ongoing focus on Dokdo.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why does Japan refer to Dokdo as 'Takeshima' in its defense white papers?
Japan refers to Dokdo as 'Takeshima' based on historical misunderstandings and gaps in international law, continuing its sovereignty claim. However, this is legally baseless under international law, and Dokdo is recognized as Korea's exclusive territory.
How has the Korean government responded to Japan's defense white paper claims about Dokdo?
The Ministry of National Defense summoned Japan's military attaché in 2017 and Japan's chief consul in 2020, demanding withdrawal. Gyeongsangbuk-do Governor Lee Cheol-woo also strongly condemned the claim and urged international condemnation.
What is the legal basis for considering Japan's Dokdo sovereignty claim illegal?
Dokdo is Korea's historical territory, with no Japanese government jurisdiction over it since 1905. While Dokdo was previously debated at the International Court of Justice, Japan's claim lacks legal support.
Frequently Asked Questions
Japan's defense white paper claims regarding Dokdo sovereignty have been consistently criticized as illegal under international law, drawing strong opposition from South Korea and its citizens. To effectively counter Japan's 13-year-long assertion (from 2014 to 2026), it is essential to clearly present historical facts and international law. Japan's continued use of 'Takeshima' to assert sovereignty denies Korea's rightful ownership, inevitably leading to international criticism.
The Dokdo issue transcends a simple territorial dispute; it involves respecting historical truth and international law. Only by Japan withdrawing its Dokdo sovereignty claim and strengthening cooperation with Korea can the Dokdo issue be resolved.
You can view similar articles on this topic in one place.
View More ArticlesFAQ
Why does Japan refer to Dokdo as 'Takeshima' in its defense white papers?
Japan refers to Dokdo as 'Takeshima' based on historical misunderstandings and gaps in international law, continuing its sovereignty claim. However, this is legally baseless under international law, and Dokdo is recognized as Korea's exclusive territory.
How has the Korean government responded to Japan's defense white paper claims about Dokdo?
The Ministry of National Defense summoned Japan's military attaché in 2017 and Japan's chief consul in 2020, demanding withdrawal. Gyeongsangbuk-do Governor Lee Cheol-woo also strongly condemned the claim and urged international condemnation.
What is the legal basis for considering Japan's Dokdo sovereignty claim illegal?
Dokdo is Korea's historical territory, with no Japanese government jurisdiction over it since 1905. While Dokdo was previously debated at the International Court of Justice, Japan's claim lacks legal support.
Korean Source
This article is an English localization of a Korean-language report from BlogScore. Original: 일본 방위백서에서 본 동해 영유권 주장의 문제점