Japan's Defense White Paper and the Dokdo Sovereignty Dispute: International Reactions from the US and Europe
International Reactions to Japan's Defense White Paper on Dokdo Sovereignty
Japan's Defense White Paper has consistently referred to Dokdo as part of its territory for the 21st and 22nd consecutive years, provoking strong reactions from the South Korean government and the international community. While the U.S. and Europe did not directly criticize Japan's claim, they framed their responses in the context of countering China's military buildup and addressing the Taiwan issue.
In July 2021, a set of 20 historical maps jointly released by Europe and Japan were presented as evidence proving Dokdo belongs to South Korea. These maps served as critical counter-evidence to Japan's claims. Following a visit by the Chonguk Innovation Party to Dokdo in May 2024, the Japanese government reiterated its stance that 'Dokdo is our land.'
The Ongoing Nature of the Dokdo Sovereignty Dispute
Japan's assertion of sovereignty over Dokdo has been repeated for 17 consecutive years in its Defense White Paper. In July 2021, Japan's Defense White Paper first mentioned the Taiwan issue while strengthening its policy to counter China's military capabilities, raising concerns that Japan's defense policies are heightening tensions in Northeast Asia.
The South Korean government immediately protested Japan's inclusion of Dokdo as part of its territory and demanded an immediate withdrawal of this claim. It summoned Japan's chief consul and defense attaché as part of a firm response. Meanwhile, the Japanese Ministry of Foreign Affairs stated that it could not accept South Korea's activities around Dokdo, reiterating that Japan does not regard the Dokdo issue as an international dispute.
Specific Reactions from the U.S. and Europe
The United States encouraged peaceful resolution between South Korea and Japan on the Dokdo issue but did not take specific measures. The U.S. has not issued any formal criticism of Japan's Defense White Paper, instead emphasizing policies to counter China and addressing the Taiwan issue in its defense strategy.
Europe also refrained from directly criticizing Japan's claim regarding Dokdo. While Europe and Japan jointly released 20 historical maps proving Dokdo belongs to South Korea, Europe focused more on countering China and addressing the Taiwan issue rather than criticizing Japan's defense policies.
The International Context of the Dokdo Sovereignty Dispute
The dispute over Japan's claim to Dokdo has persisted since 2021. Japan has even distributed educational materials for children to reinforce its position, indicating that the Japanese government views this issue not merely as a historical debate but as part of a broader strategy to secure territorial claims on the international stage.
Japan's Defense White Paper includes content addressing China's military buildup, leading some to connect Japan's Dokdo claim with its heightened vigilance toward China. By first mentioning the Taiwan issue in its Defense White Paper, Japan has reinforced its policy of countering China's influence.
Korean Government Response and International Cooperation
The South Korean government protested Japan's inclusion of Dokdo as part of its territory in the Defense White Paper, demanding an immediate withdrawal. It summoned Japan's chief consul and defense attaché, a move contrasting with Japan's stance that it does not consider Dokdo an international dispute.
Internationally, Europe's release of 20 historical maps has been used as crucial evidence proving Dokdo belongs to South Korea. This provided significant counter-evidence to Japan's claims and strengthened South Korea's position in the international community regarding the Dokdo issue.
The Connection Between Dokdo and China Containment
Japan's Defense White Paper emphasizes policies to counter China's military capabilities, having first mentioned the Taiwan issue. This suggests a view that Japan links its Dokdo sovereignty claim with its strategic concerns about China. While the U.S. encouraged peaceful resolution between South Korea and Japan on Dokdo, it focused more on the Taiwan issue in relation to Japan's policy of countering China.
The U.S. has not directly criticized Japan's defense policies regarding China containment but instead emphasized the Taiwan issue as part of its strategic approach.

Persistence of International Disputes and Future Outlook
Japan's Defense White Paper continues to refer to Dokdo as Japanese territory for the 22nd consecutive year, exacerbating tensions in the international community. Japan has also distributed educational materials for children to reinforce its claim, suggesting that disputes over Dokdo will persist.
The U.S. and Europe avoided direct criticism of Japan's Dokdo claim but linked their responses to China containment and the Taiwan issue. This indicates that Japan's defense policy goes beyond the Dokdo sovereignty dispute, aiming to strengthen its strategic position in Northeast Asia.
Verified Information and Reference Materials
Japan has consistently asserted sovereignty over Dokdo for 17 consecutive years in its Defense White Paper, suggesting the Japanese government views this issue not as a historical or international debate but as part of a territorial strategy. Europe's release of 20 historical maps was used as key evidence proving Dokdo belongs to South Korea.
The South Korean government protested Japan's inclusion of Dokdo in its Defense White Paper and summoned Japan's chief consul and defense attaché, contrasting with Japan's statement that it does not consider Dokdo an international dispute.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many years has Japan's Defense White Paper been referring to Dokdo as part of its territory?
Japan's Defense White Paper has referred to Dokdo as part of its territory for 21-22 consecutive years. This practice began in 2021, and the Japanese government has even distributed educational materials for children to reinforce this claim.
What was the U.S. stance on Japan's Dokdo claim?
The United States encouraged peaceful resolution between South Korea and Japan but did not take specific measures. The U.S. emphasized policies to counter China and address the Taiwan issue rather than directly criticizing Japan's claim regarding Dokdo.
How did Europe respond to Japan's Dokdo claim?
Europe did not directly criticize Japan's claim about Dokdo, but it provided historical maps showing Dokdo belongs to South Korea. These maps were presented as critical counter-evidence to Japan's claims.
Frequently Asked Questions
The dispute over Dokdo in Japan's Defense White Paper has persisted for 21-22 years. While the South Korean government demanded an immediate withdrawal of this claim and summoned Japanese officials, the U.S. and Europe avoided direct criticism but linked their responses to China containment and Taiwan issues.
The Dokdo sovereignty dispute is viewed not merely as a historical conflict but as part of Japan's strategic defense policy aimed at strengthening its position in Northeast Asia. This contributes to heightened tensions in the region, with ongoing disputes expected to continue.
Europe and Japan's release of 20 historical maps has been used as key evidence proving Dokdo belongs to South Korea. However, Japan continues to label Dokdo as part of its territory, exacerbating international tensions and highlighting the need for efforts toward peaceful resolution.
You can explore more articles on similar topics.
View Related ArticlesFAQ
How many years has Japan's Defense White Paper been referring to Dokdo as part of its territory?
Japan's Defense White Paper has referred to Dokdo as part of its territory for 21-22 consecutive years. This practice began in 2021, and the Japanese government has even distributed educational materials for children to reinforce this claim.
What was the U.S. stance on Japan's Dokdo claim?
The United States encouraged peaceful resolution between South Korea and Japan but did not take specific measures. The U.S. emphasized policies to counter China and address the Taiwan issue rather than directly criticizing Japan's claim regarding Dokdo.
How did Europe respond to Japan's Dokdo claim?
Europe did not directly criticize Japan's claim about Dokdo, but it provided historical maps showing Dokdo belongs to South Korea. These maps were presented as critical counter-evidence to Japan's claims.
Korean Source
This article is an English localization of a Korean-language report from BlogScore. Original: 일본 방위백서 독도 주권 논란, 미국과 유럽의 반응은?