Historian Clarifies Ancestral Ties in Actor Ha Young's Family Controversy
Historian Confirms No Clear Evidence of Pro-Japanese Collaboration by Actor Ha Young's Great-Grandfather
Historian Sim Yong-hwan has clearly stated that labeling actor Ha Young's great-grandfather An Sang-ho as a 'pro-Japanese collaborator' lacks academic validity. His remarks, made in the context of debates over inclusion in the Pro-Japanese Collaborators Database and discussions about 'disgraceful crimes,' call for a more cautious approach.
Sim Yong-hwan emphasized that the 'degree of pro-Japanese collaboration' must be considered, arguing that applying simplistic labels to historical figures without concrete evidence or historical context is inappropriate. This represents a call to re-examine the criteria used in evaluating individuals with confirmed pro-Japanese activities.
Ha Young publicly issued a personal apology for his great-grandfather's alleged pro-Japanese actions, but Sim Yong-hwan explicitly stated that such labeling itself is incorrect. His position has sparked new discussions about how historical figures should be evaluated.
Sim Yong-hwan provided specific factual evidence regarding the Pro-Japanese Collaborators Database. An Sang-ho was not listed in the database, which serves as a key reason why he cannot be simply categorized as a 'pro-Japanese collaborator.'
The historian also referenced the concept of 'disgraceful crimes,' warning against excessive politicalization of historical judgments. He stressed that even for individuals with confirmed pro-Japanese activities, labeling them without considering specific evidence and context is unjust.
Sim Yong-hwan publicly shared his views from August 11 to 13, 2026, and then made the posts private on August 16. This appears to have been done out of concern that the controversy might escalate further.

Sim Yong-hwan's 'Degree of Pro-Japanese Collaboration' Argument
Historian Sim Yong-hwan stressed the importance of considering the 'degree of pro-Japanese collaboration,' cautioning against applying simplistic labels to historical figures. This represents a call to re-examine evaluation criteria for individuals with confirmed pro-Japanese activities.
On August 11, 2026, Sim Yong-hwan first expressed his position, calling the 'pro-Japanese collaborator' label a 'dangerous idea.' This was a critique of categorizing historical figures solely based on their alleged collaboration.
On August 12, he further discussed the concept of 'disgraceful crimes,' warning against excessive politicalization in historical judgments. He emphasized that even for individuals with confirmed pro-Japanese activities, labeling them without specific evidence and context is inappropriate.
On August 13, Sim Yong-hwan reiterated his position: 'Labeling someone as a pro-Japanese collaborator lacks academic validity.' This appears to be an attempt to change how historical figures are evaluated based on their documented actions.
Sim Yong-hwan provided specific facts regarding the Pro-Japanese Collaborators Database. An Sang-ho was not listed in the database, which serves as key evidence that he cannot be simply categorized as a 'pro-Japanese collaborator.'
Even though Ha Young issued a personal apology for his great-grandfather's actions, Sim Yong-hwan clearly stated that labeling him as a pro-Japanese collaborator is incorrect. This reiterates his position that the relationship between ancestor and descendant should be considered separately.
Sim Yong-hwan made related posts private on August 16, 2026, likely to prevent further escalation of the controversy. A subsequent report on August 31 was published after Sim had already deleted the content.
Ha Young's Apology and Sim Yong-hwan's Response
After it became known that his great-grandfather An Sang-ho had pro-Japanese activities, Ha Young publicly issued a personal apology. This was seen as demonstrating responsibility as a family member.
Despite Ha Young's apology, Sim Yong-hwan clearly stated that the act of labeling someone as a 'pro-Japanese collaborator' is incorrect. His position has sparked new discussions about how historical figures should be evaluated.
Sim Yong-hwan reiterated his stance that 'a person's achievements do not affect their descendants.' This reflects concerns about descendants facing unfair consequences due to the actions of ancestors with confirmed pro-Japanese activities.
On August 13, 2026, Sim Yong-hwan stated, 'Labeling someone as a pro-Japanese collaborator lacks academic validity,' emphasizing that even for individuals with documented pro-Japanese activities, labeling them without specific evidence and context is inappropriate.
In summary, Sim Yong-hwan's position is that the 'degree of pro-Japanese collaboration' must be considered, and applying simplistic labels is undesirable. This represents a call to re-examine how historical figures are evaluated based on concrete facts and context.
Verification of Pro-Japanese Collaborators Database Inclusion
Sim Yong-hwan clearly stated that An Sang-ho was not listed in the Pro-Japanese Collaborators Database. This serves as key evidence that he cannot be simply categorized as a 'pro-Japanese collaborator.'
The Pro-Japanese Collaborators Database includes only individuals who meet specific criteria, and it appears An Sang-ho did not meet these requirements. This supports Sim Yong-hwan's argument about the need to consider the 'degree of pro-Japanese collaboration.'
Sim Yong-hwan provided specific facts regarding database inclusion: while An Sang-ho had documented pro-Japanese activities, there was insufficient evidence or contextual consideration for his inclusion.
By referencing the concept of 'disgraceful crimes,' Sim Yong-hwan warned against excessive politicalization in historical judgments. He stressed that even for individuals with confirmed pro-Japanese activities, labeling them without specific evidence and context is inappropriate.
Sim Yong-hwan's position has contributed to resolving debates about database inclusion. His argument emphasizes the need to consider concrete facts and context when evaluating historical figures.
Sim Yong-hwan's Call for Cautious Application of Pro-Japanese Labels
Sim Yong-hwan emphasized that the 'degree of pro-Japanese collaboration' must be considered, cautioning against simplistic application of labels. This represents a call to re-examine evaluation criteria for historical figures.
From August 11 to 13, 2026, Sim Yong-hwan publicly shared his views over three consecutive days. During this period, he highlighted that the 'pro-Japanese collaborator' label is a 'dangerous idea,' urging caution in its application.
By referencing the concept of 'disgraceful crimes,' Sim Yong-hwan warned against excessive politicalization in historical judgments. He emphasized that even for individuals with confirmed pro-Japanese activities, labeling them without specific evidence and context is inappropriate.
Sim Yong-hwan provided specific facts regarding database inclusion: An Sang-ho was not listed in the Pro-Japanese Collaborators Database, which supports his argument about considering the 'degree of pro-Japanese collaboration.'
On August 16, 2026, Sim Yong-hwan made related posts private, likely to prevent further escalation. A subsequent report on August 31 was published after he had already deleted the content.
Sim Yong-hwan's Proposed Historical Figure Evaluation Criteria
Sim Yong-hwan argued that evaluation criteria for historical figures need re-examination. This emphasizes that even individuals with confirmed pro-Japanese activities should not be labeled without specific evidence and context.
He stressed the importance of considering the 'degree of pro-Japanese collaboration,' cautioning against simplistic labels. This represents a call to re-examine how historical figures are evaluated based on concrete facts and context.
Regarding database inclusion, Sim Yong-hwan provided specific facts: for An Sang-ho, while there were documented pro-Japanese activities, the evidence was insufficient or contextual factors were not considered.
By referencing 'disgraceful crimes,' he warned against excessive politicalization in historical judgments. He stressed that even for individuals with confirmed pro-Japanese activities, labeling them without specific evidence and context is inappropriate.
Sim Yong-hwan's position has proposed new criteria for evaluating historical figures. His argument emphasizes the importance of considering concrete evidence and context rather than applying simplistic labels.
Summary of Sim Yong-hwan's Position
Historian Sim Yong-hwan has clearly stated that labeling actor Ha Young's great-grandfather An Sang-ho as a 'pro-Japanese collaborator' lacks academic validity. His remarks, made in the context of debates over database inclusion and 'disgraceful crimes,' call for a more cautious approach.
Sim Yong-hwan emphasized the need to consider the 'degree of pro-Japanese collaboration,' cautioning against simplistic labeling. This represents a call to re-examine evaluation criteria for historical figures.
Even after Ha Young issued a personal apology, Sim Yong-hwan clearly stated that labeling his great-grandfather as a 'pro-Japanese collaborator' is incorrect. This reinforces his position that the relationship between ancestor and descendant should be considered separately.
Sim Yong-hwan made related posts private on August 16, 2026, likely to prevent further escalation of the controversy. A subsequent report on August 31 was published after he had already deleted the content.
His position emphasizes that historical figures should be evaluated based on concrete facts and context. This provides a key reason why simply labeling someone as a 'pro-Japanese collaborator' is difficult even for individuals with confirmed pro-Japanese activities.
Frequently Asked Questions
Did Sim Yong-hwan acknowledge An Sang-ho's pro-Japanese actions?
Sim Yong-hwan sought to re-examine evaluation criteria for historical figures with documented pro-Japanese activities. While he did not deny that An Sang-ho had such actions, he argued against simplistic 'pro-Japanese collaborator' labeling.
Why did Sim Yong-hwan delete his posts?
Sim Yong-hwan made related posts private on August 16, 2026, likely due to concerns that the controversy might escalate further. A subsequent report on August 31 was published after he had already deleted the content.
How do Ha Young's apology and Sim Yong-hwan's response differ?
Ha Young issued a personal apology for his great-grandfather's alleged pro-Japanese actions, while Sim Yong-hwan explicitly stated that labeling someone as a 'pro-Japanese collaborator' is incorrect. This has sparked new discussions about how historical figures should be evaluated.
Considering these facts, Sim Yong-hwan's position can be interpreted as calling for re-examining evaluation criteria for historical figures. His argument emphasizes the need to consider specific evidence and context rather than applying simplistic labels.
You can view a collection of similar articles on this topic in one place.
View Related ArticlesFAQ
Did Sim Yong-hwan acknowledge An Sang-ho's pro-Japanese actions?
Sim Yong-hwan sought to re-examine evaluation criteria for historical figures with documented pro-Japanese activities. While he did not deny that An Sang-ho had such actions, he argued against simplistic 'pro-Japanese collaborator' labeling.
Why did Sim Yong-hwan delete his posts?
Sim Yong-hwan made related posts private on August 16, 2026, likely due to concerns that the controversy might escalate further. A subsequent report on August 31 was published after he had already deleted the content.
How do Ha Young's apology and Sim Yong-hwan's response differ?
Ha Young issued a personal apology for his great-grandfather's alleged pro-Japanese actions, while Sim Yong-hwan explicitly stated that labeling someone as a 'pro-Japanese collaborator' is incorrect. This has sparked new discussions about how historical figures should be evaluated.
Korean Source
This article is an English localization of a Korean-language report from BlogScore. Original: 심용환 하영 증조부 친일 행적 관련 주요 사건과 기록