Ha Young's Ancestor and the Controversy Over Collaboration with Japan: Historical Context and Current Discussions


The Controversy Over Ha Young's Great-Great-Grandfather: Historical Background and Current Situation
A controversy has arisen over the alleged collaboration of Ha Young's great-great-grandfather, An Sang-ho, with Japanese forces during Korea's colonial period. According to recent reports by major media outlets including TV Chosun and YTN, Ha Young's team confirmed that her ancestor served as a member of the Daeseong Chinmokhoe Council. However, historian Sim Yong-hwan cautioned against labeling him outright as a 'collaborator,' urging a careful approach.
The controversy appears to have begun around August 11, 2026, coinciding with Ha Young's first public comment about wearing hanbok and the emergence of online tools like the 'Collaborator Scanner' website. The situation intensified when Sim Yong-hwan deleted a related article he had written, revealing further details about the debate.
The Collaborator Scanner and Re-examining a 13-Year-Old Confession
The 'Collaborator Scanner' website gained sudden attention as it was used to assess whether Ha Young's great-great-grandfather had collaborated with Japan. The site allows users to input names and compares them against historical records to determine if there is evidence of collaboration, experiencing a surge in traffic following Ha Young's comments.
YTN also revisited a 13-year-old confession by Ha Young where she reportedly stated, 'My great-great-grandfather was a collaborator; it's disgusting.' At the time, this comment did not receive significant attention.

Historical Records and Allegations Regarding An Sang-ho
The Institute for National Unification stated that An Sang-ho had engaged in collaboration with Japan, but emphasized that holding his descendants responsible was inappropriate. This aligns with Ha Young's position, as the debate continues over distinguishing historical facts from personal accountability.
An Sang-ho traveled to Japan for study in 1926 with support from the Korean government but refused to return, leading to his dismissal. Additionally, connections have been suggested between him and figures involved in the assassination of Empress Myeongseong, though further verification is needed.
Drastic Production Pause and Return
Ha Young's drama 'Seungsan Itda' (There Is a Victory) was temporarily halted due to the controversy but appears to have resumed filming as of August 20. SBS and her agency stated they are taking the matter seriously, discussing it from multiple angles, though officially confirmed that production is continuing with its original schedule.
Some media outlets reported that 'Seungsan Itda' might lose momentum due to the controversy, but the production team indicated they are exploring various options for future projects.
Historian Sim Yong-hwan's Warning and Related Controversy
Sim Yong-hwan warned against labeling An Sang-ho as a 'collaborator' outright, urging caution. After writing an article on the topic and subsequently deleting it, he faced criticism, though this was likely due to his deep contemplation of distinguishing historical facts from personal responsibility.
The historian's warning reflects broader societal interest in examining past governments' collaboration with Japan. This is further evidenced by a 2.7% increase in viewership for the historical special program discussing Yi Wan-yong, suggesting that the controversy has expanded into cultural content.
Investigation of Collaborator Assets and Potential Further Investigations
An Sang-ho may be considered as a potential subject for investigation by the Second Committee on Collaborator Assets. This suggests the need for comprehensive review of historical facts, with ongoing public debate expected to continue.
The Institute for National Unification reiterated that while An Sang-ho's collaboration was clear, holding his descendants accountable is inappropriate. This serves as an important reference point in distinguishing between historical events and personal responsibility.
Response and Safety Information
Ha Young's team confirmed her great-great-grandfather served on the Daeseong Chinmokhoe Council but noted this may not directly relate to collaboration. In response to Sim Yong-hwan's warning, they are taking a careful approach to minimize public controversy.
The drama production team is discussing the issue from multiple angles and continuing with scheduled filming, likely as an effort to minimize audience inconvenience.
Key Information to Verify
It has been confirmed through the Institute for National Unification's statement and historical records that An Sang-ho engaged in collaboration. However, both Sim Yong-hwan and the Institute emphasized that holding descendants accountable is inappropriate.
Additional items requiring verification include: 1) Specific historical records of An Sang-ho's collaborative actions, 2) Activities as a member of the Daeseong Chinmokhoe Council, and 3) Potential connections to the assassination of Empress Myeongseong.
Frequently Asked Questions
Has it been confirmed that Ha Young's great-great-grandfather was a collaborator?
The Institute for National Unification stated An Sang-ho engaged in collaboration, but noted holding his descendants accountable is inappropriate.
Was the filming of Ha Young's drama 'Seungsan Itda' suspended?
The drama was temporarily halted due to controversy but resumed as of August 20. Her agency and SBS confirmed that production continues with its original schedule.
What warning did historian Sim Yong-hwan issue?
Sim Yong-hwan cautioned against labeling 'An Sang-ho = collaborator' outright, urging a careful approach. He later deleted his article after writing it and faced criticism for this action.
Frequently Asked Questions
The controversy surrounding Ha Young's great-great-grandfather has raised important questions about distinguishing historical facts from personal responsibility. The warnings from the Institute for National Unification and Sim Yong-hwan reflect broader societal interest in examining past governments' collaboration with Japan.
This incident highlights the need for deeper discussion on how to balance individual historical background with social accountability. Ha Young's team and production staff are carefully addressing the situation, and further developments should be closely monitored.
You can view similar articles about this topic in one place.
View Related ArticlesFAQ
Has it been confirmed that Ha Young's great-great-grandfather was a collaborator?
The Institute for National Unification stated An Sang-ho engaged in collaboration, but noted holding his descendants accountable is inappropriate.
Was the filming of Ha Young's drama 'Seungsan Itda' suspended?
The drama was temporarily halted due to controversy but resumed as of August 20. Her agency and SBS confirmed that production continues with its original schedule.
What warning did historian Sim Yong-hwan issue?
Sim Yong-hwan cautioned against labeling 'An Sang-ho = collaborator' outright, urging a careful approach. He later deleted his article after writing it and faced criticism for this action.
Korean Source
This article is an English localization of a Korean-language report from BlogScore. Original: 하영 친일 증조부 관련, 역사적 기록과 현재 논의