KOSUNI KOREA
Korean News in English
News

Chief Justice Cho's Written Nomination Sparks Constitutional Crisis with Blue House

Published September 20, 2026 · 4 views
Chief Justice Cho's Written Nomination Sparks Constitutional Crisis with Blue House

Chief Justice's Written Nomination Sparks Constitutional Crisis

Chief Justice Cho Hee-dae submitted a written nomination for Judge Son Bong-gi, but the Blue House rejected the appointment on grounds of "undermining procedural fairness," demanding a re-nomination. This marks the first time in constitutional history that such an issue has arisen. Chief Justice Cho expressed regret over causing concern and announced he would release an official statement next week, while the ruling party is increasing pressure for re-nomination due to concerns about court operations being disrupted by two vacant Supreme Court positions.

Procedural Issues and Blue House-Supreme Court Conflict

On August 18, Chief Justice Cho submitted a written nomination for Judge Son Bong-gi as a Supreme Court justice. However, the Blue House rejected the appointment due to "lack of procedural completeness," labeling it an "unprecedented unilateral notification" in constitutional history and demanding re-nomination. While Chief Justice Cho's office claims negotiations took place, the Blue House is pressing for re-nomination on procedural grounds.

On August 21, the Blue House stated that Chief Justice Cho's written nomination constitutes an "unprecedented unilateral notification," warning it could undermine the president's appointment power. The Supreme Court Administrative Chief explained that the decision falls under the Chief Justice's authority, but the Blue House formalized its demand for re-nomination to protect the president's appointment rights.

Disruption in Court Operations Due to Vacant Positions

Chief Justice Cho submitted written nominations for two Supreme Court justices, but with the Blue House rejecting the appointments, two vacancies have become a reality. This has raised concerns about disruptions to court operations, prompting the ruling party to intensify pressure on Chief Justice Cho to re-nominate.

On August 26, the Supreme Court Administrative Chief stated that the decision is for the Chief Justice to make, but the Blue House continues to demand re-nomination based on "lack of procedural completeness." On August 28, Chief Justice Cho apologized for causing concern and announced he would release an official statement next week. By September 4, however, no statement had been issued, with the ruling party emphasizing concerns about court operations being disrupted by the vacancies.

Delay in Official Statement

After the Blue House formally requested re-nomination for Judge No Tae-ak on August 29, Chief Justice Cho has delayed his statement and remained silent. On August 28, he stated that he had caused concern and would release an official statement next week, but by September 4, no such statement had been made.

On August 29, JTBC reported on Chief Justice Cho's silence regarding re-nomination, with the ruling party intensifying pressure over concerns about court operations being disrupted. Media outlets like Kyunghyang Shinmun and Maeil Sinmun reported on September 8 that pressure from the ruling party on Chief Justice Cho has intensified.

An Unprecedented Constitutional Situation

The Blue House has labeled Chief Justice Cho's written nomination an "unprecedented unilateral notification" in constitutional history, demanding re-nomination to prevent the president's appointment power from being undermined. This marks the first time such a situation has occurred, deepening tensions between the Blue House and Supreme Court.

Chief Justice Cho explained that he bypassed the customary face-to-face meeting with the president by submitting his nomination in writing, but noted there was no opportunity for direct dialogue with the president. The Supreme Court Administrative Chief stated that "there's no intention to fight," but the Blue House has formalized its demand for re-nomination on procedural grounds.

Controversy Over Legitimacy of Nomination Procedure

The Blue House has demanded re-nomination, citing a "lack of procedural completeness" regarding Chief Justice Cho's written nomination. However, his office claims negotiations took place, sparking a debate between "disregarding the president" versus "legitimate nomination rights." On August 19, media coverage highlighted escalating conflict and concerns about the nomination power being undermined.

Chief Justice Cho apologized to the public for causing concern and announced he would release an official statement next week. However, due to mounting public pressure, his statement has been delayed.

Court Operations Disruption and Ruling Party Pressure

The reality of two vacant Supreme Court positions has raised concerns about disruptions to court operations, prompting the ruling party to strongly demand re-nomination from Chief Justice Cho. This is a critical issue for maintaining normal judicial functions, drawing significant attention from both the public and legal community.

The Blue House demands re-nomination to prevent "undermining the president's appointment power," while Chief Justice Cho remains silent on his position, delaying his official statement. This has intensified tensions between the Supreme Court and Blue House, creating a constitutional crisis never before seen in South Korea's history.

Key Facts to Verify

Chief Justice Cho's written nomination broke with precedent, and the Blue House demanded re-nomination on grounds of "lack of procedural completeness." On August 28, he apologized for causing concern and promised an official statement next week. By September 4, however, no statement had been issued. The ruling party is intensifying pressure over concerns about court operations being disrupted by two vacant Supreme Court positions.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why did Chief Justice Cho break with precedent in his written nomination?

Chief Justice Cho bypassed the customary face-to-face meeting with the president, submitting his nomination in writing. He explained that no opportunity for direct dialogue with the president arose.

Why is the Blue House demanding re-nomination?

The Blue House claims a "lack of procedural completeness" and demands re-nomination to prevent the president's appointment power from being undermined.

Why has Chief Justice Cho delayed his official statement?

On August 28, he apologized for causing concern and promised an official statement next week. However, due to public pressure, he has remained silent and delayed his statement as of September 4.

Frequently Asked Questions

The written nomination by Chief Justice Cho and the Blue House's demand for re-nomination have created a constitutional crisis never before seen in South Korea. This conflict between presidential appointment authority and the Supreme Court's nomination rights poses risks of disrupting court operations. While Chief Justice Cho apologized to the public and promised an official statement, his delay has intensified pressure from the ruling party. The situation remains unresolved, with continued tensions between the Blue House and Supreme Court, raising questions about whether the vacancies will disrupt judicial operations.

조희대 대법관 서면 제청, 법원 차례와 절차 정리 설명 이미지

Read More Related Articles

You can view more articles on this topic in one place.

View Related Articles

FAQ

Why did Chief Justice Cho break with precedent in his written nomination?

Chief Justice Cho bypassed the customary face-to-face meeting with the president, submitting his nomination in writing. He explained that no opportunity for direct dialogue with the president arose.

Why is the Blue House demanding re-nomination?

The Blue House claims a "lack of procedural completeness" and demands re-nomination to prevent the president's appointment power from being undermined.

Why has Chief Justice Cho delayed his official statement?

On August 28, he apologized for causing concern and promised an official statement next week. However, due to public pressure, he has remained silent and delayed his statement as of September 4.

Korean Source

This article is an English localization of a Korean-language report from BlogScore. Original: 조희대 대법관 서면 제청, 법원 차례와 절차 정리