Business Owner Compensation Procedures Amid Local Government Restrictions on Sole-Source Contracts
Local Government Restrictions on Sole-Source Contracts
Local governments have introduced new regulations to prevent misconduct in public procurement by restricting sole-source contracts. The rules limit the number of times and total amount a single company can be awarded such contracts, including a provision that prohibits changing initial bid terms after two failed tenders.
Specifically, a policy allowing up to five sole-source contracts per year with a maximum of 200 million won (approximately $150,000) per company has been announced. This is seen as an effort to prevent "workaround" sole-source contracting practices. Some regions are further strengthening these measures to prevent misconduct in public procurement.
Legal Disputes and Policy Changes Related to Sole-Source Contracts
New restrictions on sole-source contracts have led to legal disputes among businesses. The rule prohibiting changes to initial bid terms after two failed tenders limits business flexibility, and indirect losses from suspension or business restrictions are not recognized in compensation claims.
Seoul City and Gangseo District Office have implemented various policies to prevent "workarounds" in redevelopment and renovation projects, such as removing requirements for construction companies to submit bid commitment letters or restricting sole-source contracts. Since 2017, a regulation allowing sole-source contracts after two failed tenders in renovation projects has been in place, seen as a measure to reduce business burdens.
Compensation Cases Related to the Four Major Rivers Cartel
The Four Major Rivers cartel case is a notable example of misconduct related to sole-source contracts. Construction companies involved in this case were ordered to pay 236.3 billion won (approximately $180 million) to the Water Resources Corporation. This case illustrates how collusion in public procurement can cause significant damage.
Gangseo District Office removed requirements for construction companies to submit bid commitment letters in the Banghwa 6-dong redevelopment project, seen as a measure to prevent "workaround" sole-source contracts in renovation projects. Seoul City has also taken action against the growing practice of "bid participation commitment letters" related to such workarounds.
Policy Shortening Land Compensation Reconsideration Periods
An additional change related to redevelopment involves shortening the land compensation reconsideration period by more than one month. This policy has been in effect since 2017, aimed at reducing inconvenience for residents.
In renovation projects, sole-source contracts became possible after two failed tenders, seen as a measure to reduce business burdens. However, some argue this rule may limit business flexibility.
Status and Challenges of Sole-Source Contract Restrictions
While local governments have implemented measures to regulate sole-source contracts, businesses are suffering losses due to these restrictions. Particularly problematic is the lack of recognition for indirect losses from suspension or business restrictions in compensation claims.
The restrictions aim to prevent misconduct in public procurement but also increase burdens on businesses. In response, the Tax Accountants Association has suggested reasonable alternatives in the revised tax law implementation decree, calling for adjustments that reflect on-site challenges.
Potential Policy Improvements for Sole-Source Contracts
Various policy improvements are being considered to address shortcomings in sole-source contract restrictions. For example, allowing changes to initial bid terms after two failed tenders could provide greater flexibility.
Additionall, measures should be explored to recognize indirect losses from suspension or business restrictions in compensation claims, enabling businesses to receive compensation for damages caused by misconduct.
Key Controversies Surrounding Sole-Source Contract Restrictions
Controversy surrounds the sole-source contract restriction policy. Some argue it limits business flexibility and that increasing litigation is due to insufficient recognition of indirect losses.
Conversely, the government promotes this as a measure to prevent "sole-source contract hoarding," though businesses report increased burdens during implementation.
Major Legal Disputes Related to Sole-Source Contracts
Litigation related to "workaround" sole-source contracts in redevelopment projects has been reported. Seoul City has taken action against the growing practice of "bid participation commitment letters" related to such workarounds, while Gangseo District Office removed requirements for construction companies to submit bid commitment letters in the Banghwa 6-dong project.
The Four Major Rivers cartel construction companies were ordered to pay 236.3 billion won (approximately $180 million) to the Water Resources Corporation, a case demonstrating the significant damage collusion can cause in public procurement.
Key Laws Related to Sole-Source Contract Restrictions
Sole-source contract restrictions are implemented based on laws such as the Public Procurement Act and the Rules for Construction Bidding and Contracts of Local Governments. These regulations aim to prevent unnecessary increases in sole-source contracts.
While these measures target misconduct in public procurement, they have increased burdens on businesses.
Efficacy and Limitations of Sole-Source Contract Restrictions
The restrictions show some effectiveness in preventing misconduct in public procurement but also increase business burdens. The rule prohibiting changes to initial bid terms after two failed tenders limits business flexibility.
The issue of not recognizing indirect losses from suspension or business restrictions in compensation claims has also been raised, making it difficult for businesses to receive compensation for damages caused by misconduct.

Key Information on Sole-Source Contract Restrictions
Sole-source contracts involve awarding procurement exclusively to a single company, which can lead to misconduct. To prevent this, the government has introduced regulations limiting both the frequency and amount of such contracts for a single company.
As a result, a policy allowing up to five sole-source contracts per year with a maximum of 200 million won (approximately $150,000) per company has been announced. However, businesses are suffering losses due to these restrictions, particularly regarding the lack of recognition for indirect losses from suspension or business restrictions in compensation claims.
Alternatives for Sole-Source Contract Policy Improvements
The Tax Accountants Association is proposing reasonable alternatives to address shortcomings in sole-source contract restrictions. These proposals reflect on-site challenges and call for flexible adjustments.
Potential improvements include allowing changes to initial bid terms after two failed tenders, as well as establishing mechanisms to recognize indirect losses from suspension or business restrictions in compensation claims.
Key Debates Surrounding Sole-Source Contract Restrictions
Debates over sole-source contract restrictions have led to conflict between the government and businesses. The government aims to prevent misconduct, while businesses seek greater flexibility.
To develop a policy that protects both public procurement integrity and business rights, adjustments reflecting diverse stakeholder opinions are needed.
Key Cases and Future Outlook for Sole-Source Contracts
The Four Major Rivers cartel case is a prominent example of misconduct related to sole-source contracts, resulting in a 236.3 billion won (approximately $180 million) compensation judgment. This case highlights the severity of collusion in public procurement.
Litigation related to "workaround" sole-source contracts in redevelopment projects is increasing. While Seoul City and Gangseo District Office are taking measures to prevent this, businesses report increased burdens.
Verified Information
The exact scope and criteria for implementing sole-source contract restrictions remain unclear, making it difficult for businesses to comply with the regulations.
Specific procedures for recognizing indirect losses from suspension or business restrictions in compensation claims have not been established, leaving businesses unable to seek compensation for damages caused by misconduct.
Frequently Asked Questions
What does the sole-source contract restriction policy entail?
The sole-source contract restriction policy limits the number of times and total amount a single company can be awarded such contracts, allowing up to five per year with a maximum of 200 million won (approximately $150,000) per company.
When do disputes related to sole-source contracts arise?
Disputes occur due to the rule prohibiting changes to initial bid terms after two failed tenders and insufficient recognition of indirect losses in compensation claims, leading to increased litigation.
What are the effects of the sole-source contract restriction policy?
The policy shows some effectiveness in preventing misconduct in public procurement but also increases business burdens.
Frequently Asked Questions
The sole-source contract restriction policy was introduced to maintain the integrity of public procurement, but businesses are suffering losses due to it. Particularly problematic is the rule prohibiting changes to initial bid terms after two failed tenders and the lack of recognition for indirect losses from suspension or business restrictions in compensation claims.
As a result, there is growing need for reasonable dialogue between government and businesses to improve the policy. Only through flexible adjustments reflecting on-site challenges can public procurement integrity and business rights be protected simultaneously.
You can view similar articles in one place.
View Related ArticlesFAQ
What does the sole-source contract restriction policy entail?
The sole-source contract restriction policy limits the number of times and total amount a single company can be awarded such contracts, allowing up to five per year with a maximum of 200 million won (approximately $150,000) per company.
When do disputes related to sole-source contracts arise?
Disputes occur due to the rule prohibiting changes to initial bid terms after two failed tenders and insufficient recognition of indirect losses in compensation claims, leading to increased litigation.
What are the effects of the sole-source contract restriction policy?
The policy shows some effectiveness in preventing misconduct in public procurement but also increases business burdens.
Korean Source
This article is an English localization of a Korean-language report from BlogScore. Original: 지방 수의계약 제한으로 인한 사업자 피해 보상 절차